Cape Town Lesbians

Home Blog Homophobia Jan Moir critisizes the 'hysterical overreaction' of critics

Jan Moir critisizes the 'hysterical overreaction' of critics

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
( 11 Votes )

I'm sure by now Jan Moir needs no introduction. To be honest, before her column on Stephen Gately, I have never heard of her. This rather questionable Daily Mail column on his death, quickly skyrocketed her to "fame". Her column has sparked over 25,000 complaints to the Press Complaints Commission (PCC) - the most complaints that they have ever received about a single article. And the social media websites Twitter and Facebook has been abuzz with (mostly negative) comments about this column. However, judging from Jan Moir's remarks on Twitter (her Twitter account is only 7 days old) she seems to be enjoying the limelight, and she often tweets flippant and sometimes petty remarks in response to the drama.

Jan Moir didn't seem to like what Cape Town Lesbians blogger Kathryn Schneider (a.k.a Katka-Kapenaar) had to say about this senario. But then... over 25,000 people didn't like what Jan Moir had to say ;-)
The link she refers to in this tweet is the post written by Kathryn titled "We all learn a lesson (especially Jan Moir)"

After last week's column, all advertisements have been pulled from the web page, and instead of apologising for the views that many found offensive, she attempted to explain her comments. Today, Jan Moir wrote a column to apologise to the parents of the gay Boyzone star Stephen Gately, but she also critisized the 'hysterical overreaction' of critics. She also claimed that she has recieved thousands of supportive emails from readers. An extract:

"To say it was a hysterical overreaction would be putting it mildly, though clearly much of it was an orchestrated campaign by pressure groups and those with agendas of their own.

However, I accept that many people – on Twitter and elsewhere – were merely expressing their own personal and heartfelt opinions or grievances. This said, I can’t help wondering: is there a compulsion today to see bigotry and social intolerance where none exists by people who are determined to be outraged? Or was it a failure of communication on my part?

Certainly, something terrible went wrong as my column ricocheted through cyberspace, unread by many who complained, yet somehow generally and gleefully accepted into folklore as a homophobic rant.

It lit a spark, then a flame and turned into a roaring ball of hate fire, blazing unchecked and unmediated across the internet.

Yet as the torrent of abuse continued, most of it anonymous, I also had thousands of supportive emails from readers and well-wishers, many of whom described themselves as ‘the silent majority’. The outcry was not as one-sided as many imagine.”

 

To read this full column, click here
  

And now, the question... do you think that the public overreacted, or do you think that the reaction to her column was perhaps justified?

Comments
Add New Search
Jan is such a Moiron :P
Katka-K (84.9.120.xxx) 2009-10-23 16:46:22

I have to say, what I find most offensive about Jan Moir is not what she says (which is bad enough) but the way she says it.

Besides the constant othering and the not-very-subtle implicit 'they' tone running all the way through her column, the words she uses give away how she really feels.

Using the term "unnatural" for any gay issue would generally be avoided by anyone with a little sense.

And "hysterical"? Really? You can just hear her readers saying "Oh, well, you know how the homosexuals have a tendency to get hysterical".

No, I am not hysterical. I have a perfectly reasonable and rational mind that knows when it's being insulted.

As for her question:

"Can it really be that we are becoming a society where no one can dare to question the circumstances or behaviour of a person who happens to be gay without being labelled a homophobe?"

I would like to reply with another question:

Can it really be that we are becoming a society where no one can dare to question homophobia without being called hysterical?

That's my second two cents worth, so I'm down four cents.

Katka Out

xxxx
eastsilkway
S (122.193.88.xxx) 2010-08-19 08:28:17

Good post! Thanks for your information!Our online shop supply
2010 bridesmaid dress
2010 bridesmaid dresses
2010 cocktail dresses
2010 cocktail dress
2010 evening dress
2010 evening dresses
2010 wedding dress
2010 wedding dresses
ball dress
ball dresses
beading for dress
beading for dresses
best cocktail dress
best cocktail dresses
best evening dresses
best evening dress
bonny wedding dresses
boys cheap dress shoe
boys dress shoes
boys dress up shoes
boys wedding
boys wedding clothes
boys wedding shoes
boys wedding suit
boys wedding suits
bridal cocktail dress
bridal glove
bridal gloves
bridal gown designers
bridal jackets
bridal wedding jacket
bridal wedding jackets
bridesmaid gowns
bridesmaid gown
cheap bridal gloves
cheap bridal shoe
cheap bridal shoes
cheap chiffon dresses
cheap cocktail dress
cheap cocktail dresses
cheap suits for boys
cheap wedding dresses
cheap wedding gloves
cheap wedding shoe
cheap wedding shoes
cheap wedding veil
cheap wedding veils
chiffon beach dress
chiffon evening gown
chiffon wedding dresses
chiffon wedding dress
cocktail dress
cocktail dresses
cocktail dresses modest
cocktail party dress
custom cocktail dress
custom evening gown
custom evening gowns
custom made bridesmaid
designer evening gown
designer quinceanera dress
designer quinceanera dresses
designer wedding veils
designer wedding veil
discount wedding shoe
discount wedding veils
discount wedding veil
dress beading designs
dresses evening
elegant evening gown
ella wedding dresses
ella wedding gowns
evening dreese 2010
evening dress
evening dress chiffon
evening dresses
evening dresses 2010
evening gown
exclusive bridesmaid
flirt evening dresses
flower girl dress
flower girl dresses
flower girl shoes
flower girl shoe
jasmine bridal gowns
lace mermaid wedding
lace wedding jacket
lace wedding jackets
little boys suit
little boys suits
mens wedding shoes
men's wedding suit
mermaid wedding dress
modest cocktail dresses
modest cocktail dress
new 2010 quinceanera
new bridesmaid dresse
new dresses 2010
new style dress
new style dresses
new style dresses 2010
quinceanera 2010
quinceanera dresses
quinceanera gowns
sexy bridesmaid dresses
sexy bridesmaid dress
sexy cocktail dress
sexy cocktail dresses
sexy dresses 2010
sexy mermaid wedding
short veils
spanish evening dress
style dresses
tulle cocktail dress
tulle wedding jacket
wedding bridal veils
wedding dress
wedding dress 2010
wedding dresses 2010
wedding dress beading
wedding dress for men
wedding dress jackets
wedding dresses
wedding dresses 2010
wedding handbags
wedding handbag
wedding head dress
wedding headdress
wedding jackets
wedding jacket
wedding men dresses
wedding shawl
wedding shawls
wedding shoes
wedding shoes for boy
wedding suits 2010
wedding suit for men
wedding suits for men
wedding veil
wedding veils
white chiffon gown
wholesale quinceanera
susu
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol::kiss::D:pinch:
:(:shock::X:side::):P:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):s
:!::?::idea::arrow:
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."

Last Updated ( Friday, 23 October 2009 14:56 )  
Cape Town Lesbians


Twitter Feed


Afrigator